Do you prefer travelling 1st class or 2nd class on the trains?

On longer journeys I take 1st class, you can get the carriages with the plugs and I'll sit and watch a movie on the laptop.

I tend to upgrade

- when I'm tired, hot and cranky;

- when I've got four bags of shopping to lug home;

- as a romantic overture. Because nothing says love like a Klassenwechsel. (2nd class is snugglier though.)

2nd class every time... 1st class is just not worth it...

mind you, on the train from visp to zermatt, i normally go in 1st class; as i then can avoid the herds of skiers, families, dogs, strollers and children... 2nd class is packed, 1st is never more than half full

Second class only for short trips and if I'm the one who's paying.

Company pays first class for any work related trips I make.

If I may be permitted to quote myself ...

1st class as often as I can, unless I'm taking the Belp to Bern regional train. Then, it really is not worth it.

Personally I prefer travelling in da 2nd class as it doesn't make a difference to me on a short haul trips. One reason I might like it better cos of the 20min abandoned papers all over the place which I can pick up and browse during my short ride to work. Long distance trip preferrably upgrade to the 1st class. If you ask me I'm still a motor vehicle and bicycle person, with the former one being overkill for such a small country.

2nd class is fine between 9:00 and 4:00. At any other time the 2nd class train cars of the S Bahn on the gold coast to Zurich are packed. For me, any other time of day first class is my preferred option - in spite of the crazy price.

I come from the mid-west where we like our physical space. I'm also a tiny woman.

For me, first-class means:

· I get a seat

· No one pushes me or accidentally kicks my feet entering the train

· I don't take an elbow from the tall guys in suits who I expect to be more careful

· No one puts on make-up next to me

· Since, I’m tiny, the largest people tend to find the seat next to me attractive which means they take half of my seat as well

· I don't have to literally climb over the people who don’t get up so that someone can get to the aisle even though they can clearly see that their knees are touching the person in front of them

· No one blows their nose in my face

· People don’t tend to talk loud on their mobile phone

· No graffiti

· No hoodlums

· No drunk kids showing off

· No food or sticky drinks on the floor

· People don’t tend to eat smelly food on the way

· No end of the day body-odor from people sitting so snuggly close

Sorry, but the first class from Zurich to Bern in the morning would really disappoint you... the ICs at 7.00 or 7.30 more packed in first class till the last seat than in 2nd, people will easily push as much to get a seat when entering the train and are not in any way eating less smelly food. While there are surely less graffity or kids, people tend to talk louder on their phone! Because they are important! (I seriously overheard HR-related stuff with full names on things that I would consider very private...)

If one is traveling for less than half an hour I don't find there is a difference. Once you get over that time frame I find 1st class to be much better.

OTOH, as I usually travel with my wife and small daughter, if we can get 3 seats together we end up with a lot of room. Flying Coach isn't too bad because of this as long as we are together.

Brian.

Oh my, that is worse. I've never taken that line.

I don't want to complain. It is still better in Switzerland than in many other countries.

At least, I can find some peace on my route by taking first class.

I have to agree that 2nd class is generally more entertaining. On my first trips to Switzerland, I travelled 1st class. There tended to be considerable numbers of staid business people and retired couples on holiday. The highlight of my encounters in 1st class was watching a business man tearing the pages of his newspaper into neat squares as he read them.

Due, initially, to the fall in the exchange rate, I demoted myself to 2nd class: a good decision in many ways.

In 2nd class I shared a day with an American lady that I met on the train. We had a most enjoyable day including lunch in Gruyères. Shame she was returning back to the USA the next day.

I was chatted up on a late night train from Arbon to Zurich by some Swiss girls who were keen to share out their vodka. They seemed impressed by my English accent. (Not sure they may have been so chatty if they were sober )

On Christmas day I was fed homemade chocolates by two girls on the journey from Bern to Zurich.

It is 2nd class for me every time now

I thought you only got a second glass when travelling first class?

If you really choose to always go 2nd class when flying, I can only assume that you're small enough to curl up on the seat and get a good kip.

Have only ever been 1st class once on a train from London to Manchester, which was kind of cool.

Wouldn't bother here, I've better things to spend my money on.

Oh look I've got a better seat than you, mine has got a piece of cloth of the headrest

Surprised that noone's mentioned that a big advantage of 1st on some routes is the Quiet Zone .

It's a real tonic...

Please refrain from the following in quiet zones:

conversation and discussion, even if conducted quietly listening to music or the radio, even using headphones using audio and video applications on laptops using mobile phones Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahh

Surely not everytime then!

I have a friend (he's black but I don't know if you're allowed to say thatthese days) and he says wherever he sits, people leave him to himself.

People enter his cabin and basically turn and run.

He sees this as racism. I would see it as a blessing.

I suppose that depends on whether he's black or not.

I was on a local train last month (2nd) and could not believe my eyes when these two girls got on. One got a hair dye kit out and mixed it then proceeded to dye the other girl's hair

She then put a plastic bag on her head to stop the dye dripping and they then waited for I presume the required time for it to work.

Unfortunately I had to get off so what happened next - I don't know. Maybe they went to the sink in the WC to rinse it off

One of the funniest things I've heard. And my one complaint would be that several trains I've been on had little to no water running in the WC. But, I guess that's using your time wisely. Or maybe she was running away....