Dear all,
seems like rental income taxation is an evergreen topic but I am about to declare property I own abroad for the first time. The property is a family house and right now is going through a very expensive renovation. For that reason, it's not even rented of course.
Questions:
1. Do I still need to declare a virtual rent income (Eigenmietwert) if it's obviously not rentable at all? If so, what would be a reasonable amount? 4%?
2. the more interesting question is whether I can deduct renovation expenses and claim them as maintenance costs (for instance roof renovation or heating/electricity system replacement). This would significantly decrease my tax rate (in extreme situations it might go to zero). In ZHprivateTax software I can really deduct them and decrease my overall tax but I am really not sure whether this can be accepted by the tax authority.
3. I also have property which is a kind of flat for my parents and for that reason is also not rented. Can this argument be accepted?
In addition, I tried to contact two tax advisor companies but I have a feeling they work in the way (give us all documents and we fill out tax return accordingly). So I would be also happy if you can recommend someone who has really good knowledge and experience with this matter.
Cheers.
The very simplest is to claim it and get it sorted out by the tax office. They either accept it or correct it.
Far as I know you don’t have to give a reason why a property isn’t rented out. I just provided a theoretical valuation/rent for our UK property since we use it as a base when we’re there so don’t rent it out. Never had it queried by our Fribourg tax office.
Improvements can’t be claimed. Broken water system you probably could, but just replacing it because you want to doesn’t fall under the reclamation criteria. Same for the roof.
1. The property is not in Switzerland, thus you don’t live in it and Eigenmietwert does not apply.
2. No.
3: Don’t understand. Is this a second property abroad?
I would say you were better completing a tax declaration wherever the property in, if allowable there. All the Swiss tax office is interested in is the income from rental and the value of the property will be added to your wealth...
1. If not rented, it will assumed to be a self occupied property. You need to get an official rental valuation certificate from the home country. Alternatively if not available, a theoretical rental value can be shown at least as per GE cantonal tax law at ~4.5% of the capital value. Each canton has slightly different approach. In case the capital value of the property is very small, the authorities may even accept if you show zero rent.
2a. Yes, you may deduct repairs and replacements for foreign property IF the rental value is based on actual rent received or an official valuation. This maintainence can be claimed as a lump-sum or on actuals.
As with property in CH, it is up to the authorities to accept each expense as a repair or not. They may assess some expenses as improvements and thus increase the capital value of the property. Be sure to have invoices that clearly state: repair or replacement.
And yes, the maintenance expenses can exceed the rental valuation.
2b. If the rental value is based on the lump sum capital value, in GE calculated as 4.5% of capital value, then one may not claim repairs.
3. If the Flat which your parents live, is in your name, you are obliged to declare it. Same rules for rental value. Presumably you will want to show it is as self occupied as your parents live there.
You asked for Recommendations:
Read this : https://www.depigest.ch/images//stor...L_ETRANGER.pdf
Tax authorities in CH, at least in GE canton, are very helpful and responsive. You may want to write to them or go meet them. Surprisingly it may be a pleasant and helpful conversation.
Not how I know it: foreign property generates Eigenmietwert, which (exactly as the wealth tax on the value of foreign property) will contribute to your income tax rate but won't be taxed.
Not sure, but I think a shot at not having Eigenmietwert for an apartment that is being renovated and thus not livable.
For the one that is for your parents, as far as I know, you have to declare Eigenmietwert - you could perceive rent from someone, but you decide to gift it to your parents so they can live there. Basically you perceive rent from your parents and then decided to give it back, but it still part of the tax rate calculation
Declare rental income from your parents but at a very low rate. This will also lower the property valuation.
I rented out my house in England for 5 years in the 90s. All the Swiss tax office were interested in was its value for my world-wide wealth (Vermögensteuer). All income and expenses on the house were entered by the UK tax office.
Eigenmietwert is not worked out by the taxpayer, but estimated and advised by the local Swiss council (Gemeinde) where the property is...
Thank you all for your valuable input. It's clear that answers to those questions are not clear So I decided to visit my local tax office with the results as follows:
1. Not a clear answer. The lady asked more "senior" colleagues around and they had really long discussion about this topic. In the end, she advised that I should not write down any virtual rent as there's no income (not even potential) and I should explain the situation in notes on my tax return.
2. This is also questionable as she advised me to write down all expenses I have evidence for and then the tax inspector decides whether it will be accepted or not
3. This again depends on the tax inspector.
Looks like they miss clear procedures for such cases. I am going with the highest optimization approach and will hope for the best but be prepared for the worst (every number should be covered by some evidence if they potentially ask).
Cheers!