Reviving this thread (16 years later!) after seeing this:
The report the BBC refers to is in the link below. It involved testing whether certain sunscreens offered the protection they claimed.
It looks as if a lot of the sunscreens tested may be Australian brands. Most of the sunscreens tested didn’t offer the protection claimed.
But, of the sunscreens with familiar sounding (at least to me) brand names, a Neutrogena and a Roche-Posay sunscreen actually offered the factor 50 protection claimed. A Nivea sunscreen offered factor 40 protection rather than the factor 50 protection claimed. See the chart in the link below.