I didn’t say that, in fact I have made the same remark. Read my posts again, please.
The only part in your post that I find helpful. It is a good suggestion to deal with the same pharmacy.
Otherwise, seriously…people don’t have a blind trust in docs. It should have been obvious by now if you read other posts of mine.
I found some of them quite careful not to overcharge the insurance companies.
But venting is fine.
Edit: I got what you meant, yeah, it makes sense but I think you’re going too far with your assumptions. I don’t think they have access to this kind of data unless they ask you directly? If they need to prescribe something more expensive they usually (some of them at least) ask the insurance company first to know if they’ll cover it.
Suggestion - give up the Hausarztmodell and opt for a smaller franchise.
I am with Visana and changed my model with them for the first time to Combi Care - means I first either need to go to GP or I can call and announce my specialist visits and also have to get generics only.
Saves me quite a bit and it’s quite easy… I have lots of recurring checks and I just called in January and announced them all. For this reason a high franchise does not work for me as I know I will spend the franchise with simply the basic checks I need to do annually so this is the only way. I don’t remember the details but together with husband it’s about 3k/year which is cool.
The year I raised my franchise thinking I am in good health is the year I had an operation so not doing that again
I understand that not all cantons permit physicians to dispense meds. In Bern and Zurich they can. I actually give all my prescriptions to my GP and get them from the GP. I don’t think I pay for checks though. But I like having my prescriptions in a single place.
If you don’t go through your GP or a pharmacy, you really can’t rely on a specialist for interaction checking. Specialists are very focused on their body part of expertise.
I am very happy with my Swiss healthcare experience, although monthly premiums are high, but I came from the US shitshow of healthcare.
My OH changed to a similar model but I chickened out at the last moment!
I found a GP I get along with much better…sometimes all it takes is change your GP and be patient. Same for the pharmacy - we go to only one pharmacy/chain now. As for the costs - mine are a bit higher but I think everything will even out in the end. If not, you can do that the next year so…
In my limited experience they do care if you’re taking any other medication. Of course you can’t rely on them 100% and maybe having a safety net and the pharmacist going through your prescription every time is helpful for most; I wouldn’t know that.
But I also understand the frustration of seeing a fee attached to it every single month. I actually don’t remember when upon presenting a prescription for whatever illness they asked if we take any other medicines. They were more preoccupied to tell you how to take whatever was prescribed there.
My frustration is that people can’t seem to understand that there are a number of reasons for this fee and tasks which must be undertaken by the pharmacist every time a prescription is collected.
Before the current fee, there used to be a percentage added to the cost but people with high-value prescriptions didn’t think this was fair as the work carried out by the pharmacist was the same, irrespective of the cost of the medicine.
OK, I get it, but the level of this fee seems a bit high if you sum up every monthly prescription as per 3Wishes’s post. And this alone adds up to other costs and fees I am not even aware of. I guess where we mainly disagree here is the pharmacist being an infallible medical agent hence the justification of the fee. Yes, they do have costs too, fair enough.
Nobody has ever said that pharmacists are an infallible medical agent. Wherever did you get that idea from?
They are a useful safety net and carry out a service which takes up their time so why shouldn’t they charge for it?
You said the checks were highly unnecessary which is definitely not true.
I think we both have written some things that could be interpretable. It was my feeling after reading your post, but maybe it’s just a misunderstanding.
Yes, I did say that but was thinking of the cases when you do have a GP which was a bit shortsighted from my part. I didn’t mean they are entirely or always unnecessary.
I can also argue that you literally said that I have a “blind trust” in docs checking the interactions which I also don’t know where you got that from as I never said that.
Agree, what was datable in my view was the level of their fees.
We could try a half way house where the government offers good value health insurance and has to compete with the private sector. If they can truely offer cost savings, then this will drive down prices.
Last year I missed the deadline to cancel my supplementary health insurance and thus stayed one more year with current health insurance company. I will change this year to the telmed model, what komsomolez described. Better do it before summer to comply with notification time.
So, I already compared some prices and the lowest ones for Aargau are CSS, sanitas, Helsana. To my surprise, I looked for the market share of health insurance companies and I see Swica having 2nd largest marketshare.
I remember Swica because once I saw some publicity at the gym. This company offers price “reductions” if you “do exercise”. Caveat? The monthly price before reduction is relatively high. Thus, the price after the discount is still higher than cheaper insurers.
So, is the system working? Are consumers being rational and choosing the cheapest one?
Most people don’t change insurance, I think I read somewhere it’s only 20%. I for one do not want the hassle of a separate basic and private insurance for a 50 chf saving each month and I would never take the cheapest (likely to be Assura) because their incompetence is well documented.
So it’s not really a competitive market as past a certain age you are locked in with one insurance really…
By the way I think the model change (I.e. telmed Vs GP etc) has different deadlines to change it.
Inertia is a huge thing for consumers. We’ve kept SWICA for a while and use the Telmed model, low franchise so our premiums are high. But we’re in our 60s, have prescriptions and some recurring exams and treatment. The customer service is decent, and pretty much everything goes straight from the doctor to the insurance. The telmed model is not intrusive at all.
There are so many insurers, probably far too many. I do comparisons periodically, but I’m not going to save enough money to make it worth it so far. And that’s why we have inertia. I pay for convenience.
I know that prescription costs are high, but we only pay 10% after we hit the franchise, usually in January.
We don’t have supplemental insurance, because we could not qualify. But right now, that’s where you can get some reimbursement for exercise and so forth.
I agree that the level of these fees does seem disproportionately high.
Over on EF a certain Jurassian dinosaur argued that the fees were there to ensure that rural pharmacies were adequately funded and remained in business as they were a necessity for elderly people in isolated areas. I don’t know how that was supposed to work exactly.
For people with the GP model the checks are probably less of a necessity but the pharmacist doesn’t know what insurance model you have so just does a blanket check on everyone.
This is a good example. There are many providers, but little competition. First thing is to allow switching of providers at any time with no penalty and simply paying pro-rata.
The sheer number of providers indicates that they are too profitable if they can survive with such tiny market shares.
If change of health insurance company is possible all the year, it would lower the workload of people in them in the months before November. So, they can reduce the number of workers, lower costs, etc.
Also, how many francs are spent in the spam calls and those pesky sellers visiting you at home to make you change from health insurance provider? This is more than an annoyance, borderline illegal and we pay for it. It would be nice if health insurance companies are forced to disclose how much they pay subcontractors for this dirty work.