For the record, let's call them Swiss, since that's their post-bankruptcy name.
Me and my wife also had a nightmarish experience with them in June '07, and the consumer magazine K-Tipp confirmed that this sort of thing can happen.
We had a flight booked from Zurich to Montreal CA, where a rental car was waiting for us. Our plan was, roughly, to drive around from awhile and end up back in Montreal to fly home, after returning the car.
Well, my wife is from a country that technically didn't require visas anymore for Canada, but as it turned out, the agreement hadn't been ratified yet - so she still needed one. I messed up by not getting one for her. But boy did we suffer thanks to that one mistake...
First, we checked in our bags at the Zurich airport. The Swiss agent first told us "hey, she needs a visa!" and we got nervous - but then she checked the text on her screen and decided she didn't need a visa after all. In fact she mis-interpreted the text, which was missing a period and seemed to say one thing but meant another.
ANYWAY, so we went to the gate, having checked in our suitcases. We were a bit on the late side. Well, when we tried to check in, whaddya know - they told my wife she couldn't get on the plane w/out a visa. WHAT? We were just told she could? Well, they weren't budging since they have to pay for her flight back to CH if the authorities in Canada "have" to send her back home once she gets there.
So we had to decide within a minute whether to have them dig out our 2 suitcases and we both stay home, or I go alone and she finds her own way. We chose the latter.
NOW: get this. There were plenty of people who saw what happened and why she wasn't allowed onto the plane, right? Well, her ticket was CANCELLED, simply because Swiss has a policy that if you're not on the trip there, you can't come home either. It's to prevent people from buying 2-way tickets when they really just want 1-way (which is usu. more expensive). But even under these circumstances they didn't want to budge!
Not only that, but they didn't tell my wife that she at LEAST has the right to get back her airport fees - she knew it herself, and had to argue a bit with one guy at the Swiss counter until he paid her that part back.
So, meanwhile I arrive in Montreal alone with both of our suitcases.
Because we had a specific route planned, it all became very complicated...my wife had to fly to Paris first because the embassy in CH doesn't issue travel visas(!) So she ended up on an Air France flight. In Paris she had a few hours changeover to get herself visa, which was a nightmare in of its own. But that's not part of the "Swiss" story.
It made life REALLY HARD for us that Swiss simply didn't let her use the return portion of her ticket because of their stubborn policy. In resulted in
- a Swiss agent in Montreal working for *days* to try and find a workaround for us!
- me and my wife flying out of New York instead of Montreal - get this - MY flight with Swiss was still valid, so they actually diverted my return flight from NYC, to match my wife's flight - which was also out of NYC (the flights out of Montreal were too expensive).
In other words, one of Swiss' OWN AGENTS had to go to a lot of trouble because of THEIR OWN stubbornness.
Not only that, it also meant that I couldn't return the rental car to the Montreal airport, so I had to leave it Rochester NY (long story) - WITH a return fee of course! - and get local flights for us both from Rochester to NYC so we could finally get home.
To sum up, because of Swiss' rule -which is meant to prevent cheating- and their unwillingness to make an exception EVEN when it was clear that we weren't cheating, they caused THEIR OWN employee in Montreal a couple of days worth of trouble (not even SHE could convince them to allow my wife to use her return ticket!) re-organizing things for me, so I could go home with my wife.
And our trip became 2 or 3000 of thousand CHF more expensive in the end, with phone calls left and right, plenty of stress, and a nearly perfectly ruined vacation plan.
YES, it was our mistake to being with, but the complete lack of understanding from Swiss - even to the detriment of one of their own employees! - is something I'll never forget. It remains a black spot in my memory...
I continue to avoid Swiss to this day, and I will continue to avoid it if possible.