Whats the best book to learn German?

I agree.

The best class for me *, the class that by far helped me the most in 'real life', was one where the textbook was the daily newspaper. We started with the 20minutes, progressed (if you can call it that ) to the Blick, then the Tagi, then the NZZ.

We'd read an article, then discuss it. I picked up far more useful vocabulary, developed a better understanding of grammar, using this approach than I did in any class using a traditional textbook.

*Note that I said 'for me'. It really is difficult to say that one method or another is 'the best', as we all learn differently. The important thing is to understand how you learn most effectively, and then find an course/book based on that.

Based on the replies above I would probably suggest "Der Fragebogen. Datenbasis, Konstruktion und Auswertung".

I used several books for self learning like the Berlitz, Studio D, even a phrasebook of Lonely Planet as a start which helps a lot. But the best is the Grammar Book Lehr und Übungsbuch der deutschen Grammatik, Neubearbeitung: aktuell, Hueber Verlag from Dreyer/Schmitt. It is a really good one. Hope this helps. It is also really good to get the blick am abend newspaper and get the news you like and translate them, read and then speak outloud alone. I did this for a year together with the books, and learned alone in one year...good luck

Her a short list of books which are good to learn german:

- http://www.amazon.de/Die-Verwandlung...dp/3150099005/ (a classic )

- http://www.amazon.de/eiS-180%C2%B0-M.../dp/B00CDQLSHS (big vocabulary )

- http://www.amazon.de/Das-Parfum-Patr.../dp/3257228007 (odors vocabulary )

- http://www.amazon.de/James-Bond-01-C.../dp/B007VCEIT4 (J.B., just in german )

- http://www.amazon.de/Faust-Der-Trag%.../dp/3150000017 (german classic )