AI-generated content on YouTube: how to spot it

Someone has just sent me this video (edit: supposedly of George Will):

In the blurb under the video, it says:

How this was made

Altered or synthetic content

Sound or visuals were significantly edited or digitally generated. Learn more

This suggests that the guy is AI-generated and presumably the other videos with him on the channel. There are just 11 videos on the channel, all with the same guy, the oldest video from just 3 weeks ago. Channel supposedly has 57.6k subscribers.

One of the comments (most very positive and streaming in) under the video:

Y’all sure this isn’t A.I.? Seriously, something abt the way he blinks looks off to me. And why wasn’t the footage he was referring to shown? THIS is how we are being divided! While they’re feeding this to one side, they’re feeding the other side something else. PLEASE GUYS…BE AWARE!

I might not have been suspicious of this video if I hadn’t seen this, which includes a very useful tip on how to check the blurb under a video. The example of an AI-generated video she shows refers to “AI” in the blurb, but the one above doesn’t, instead saying “digitally generated”.

1 Like

The video is AI generated, part of the writing is also AI generated.

How can you tell without trusting the blurb to say it’s AI-generated/digitally generated, etc.?

The video has artifacts. If you watch him move while talking, look at the arms of his glasses, there are telltale warps.

The description also has AI hallmark constructions:

“This isn’t partisan outrage. This is pattern recognition.”

In the video there are also phrases like:

“These people aren’t serving Trump. They’re using him.”

AI loves this kind of construction. It also loves to mix it up with short staccato phrases for effect like:

“History matters. Memory matters. Accountability matters.”

Of course, current state-of-the-art AI video is already much better than what is shown here. I’ve been following closely so am used to what to look out for, but I’m not a video specialist and for sure there are videos that will catch me out.

2 Likes

What a brave new world eh?

AI still fails badly when pronouncing years and abbreviations. That’s a strong clue.

1 Like

On TikTok?

It is AI when any written part has correct spelling and grammar.

1 Like

How?

After 2,3 or 5 videos. It’s easy to deceive in a 30s short. But, no one can lie consistently for a long time.

Also, real people need money and will ask for it via patreon or something similar. People hiding behind AI sticks to youtube money.

Finally, trust your gut. Stop a video and block to your heart’s content. The world is big and full of fish, just look for the next one. Even if you mistake something legit for fraud, practically nothing is lost.

1 Like

Thanks for the tips, folks.

The AI-generated speaker in the first video in my original post is supposed to be George Will, who is a real political commentator.

Two days later, the channel of the video now has a further 20k subscribers and comments are still streaming in, second by second. Bots?

Who makes this stuff and why?

A lot of AI generated content now to get view, sell adverts etc.

1 Like

Whoever created the channel is doing very well.

1 Like

The video is now displaying a message saying that the video is no longer available as the YouTube account associated with it has been closed.