Not a fan, I have to admit.
What about a Kia Sportage? They seem very popular at the moment and are smaller than the Santa Fe. I think maybe the 7 year warranty is attractive to some people.
They may be very similar to the Tucson though, I have to admit that I've never really looked closely at either if them but there do seem to be strong similarities between Hyundai and Kia.
Funny! My Subarus never burned oil. Never had to refill them between changes.