Car vs Public Transport Convenience vs Cost

No idea what you are talking about.

The phrase means to do something with a carefree, or unrestrained manner.

The latter in this case.

Noticed some new buses running yesterday and spotted one this morning just as we were leaving; seems these new ones are powered by hydrogen fuel cells.

2 Likes

Post-Auto?

I remember some trials to be done by them. I completely forgot about it.

No, TPF - Transport Public Fribourg.

1 Like

I’ve seen many times in discussion people comparing car door-to-door times with train station-to-station times and forgetting the last mile which is the most important in many cases. If you add connections with other means (buses, trams, etc) it adds up quickly.

When I used to live a 2 min walk from Oerlikon station, I had a car and used it here and there. Now the nearest stop is a 7-10min uphill walk for me or a 15+min fight with two small children. So we go everywhere by car.

Also my commute to my last job was a 35min drive or 1.5h by public transport.

And when you start adding people to the journey the public transport cost adds up quickly. We’re thinking about a family trip to Paris and even at today’s gas prices and the absolutely insatiable thirst of all our car options, the trip is like 20% cheaper by car, even considering parking for the duration of our stay there.

Public transport works great, but like everything in life it’s not an absolute solution to everything. So pick your battles and weapons of choice wisely, budget reasonably, and don’t die on hills. I love driving, and if I could I would all day. Even I will take the train to do Zurich-Geneva for work, because nothing else makes sense.

4 Likes

With the actual laws you get a nice gift every time you use your own car: you don’t have to pay almost nothing for the damage you do. External costs are paid by others, so it is a legal method to steal from others!

The only thing that could help is road pricing everywhere, probably with an app like SBB easyride. You pay for road maintenance, the noise, the damage to air, for traffic jams, for the rest of your car tires you leave everywhere. The app would charge per vehicle type, route and time.

It just does not make sense today that car drivers can legally steal from everybody else! But unless this does not change it is the best idea to use a car instead of public transport.

Indeed. In rough numbers:

  • 1 people: train is cheaper
  • 2 people: car cost = train cost
  • 2+ people: car is cheaper

Paris parking is like 35 EUR/day, or is there a cheaper solution? :slight_smile:

As far as I understand the taxation on ICE fuels goes to a “transports fund” which is used to maintain/extend roads AND to maintain/extend other transports, including trains.

So if this is a theft, the victims are the car drivers.

1 Like

This is bad, but just a drop on a hot stone. Only the lost hours in traffic jams cost a multiple of the fuel tax (which could be eliminated by road pricing for all roads). Not to speak about environmental damage, noise, space requirements and so on.

Road pricing could be a way to control traffic. If you pay almost your whole salary just to get to work by car you may think about spending that money to live a bit closer to work or change work to a place a bit more accessible by public transportation. If you spend more for the Gotthard then for your complete holiday you may think about using your car for those holidays.

But as I said, you would be stupid not to use a private car today, because they give away money, all the external costs are paid by society. I am an egoist and therefor I own two cars and used to own two motorbikes too. But then I own two e-bikes too.

1 Like

Switzerland would be even better with congestion pricing for roads, but -1 political will for this.

Agree, one step in the right direction. But why not charge all the costs, all the roads, always. Today one who makes a lot of miles gets it cheaper than somebody who does not. That is nonsense.

Because taxation is more or less wells, enough revenue. The problem is the misuse of existing infra: having 3+ hours wait at Gotthard tunnel when there’s 0 wait after 20h00.

There’s night-time electricity prices (22h00-7h00 next day), a night time discounted train abo for the young, there could be a night time price for roads too.

Perhaps you are taking only marginal cost and not fully loaded cost? e.g. including depreciation, maintenance, opportunity/financing cost etc.

1 Like

Depreciation does depend on the car. We have 2x Lupo 3Ls. Both usually on a changeable plate so one on standby. Both 20+ years old both worth what we paid if sold without MFK (as we bought them). I do our own maintenance, the in service car is used by the family. It does 3.5l per 100km driven exactly at speed limits as you need to. It is much cheaper than the train, great for shopping. Living in Zurich you do need the train sometimes. In Jura our 2nd home public transport takes ages and it is invaluable as a backup once every few years. Uber seems strange around there. Tax and insurance is about 900chf. A new clutch this year was 150chf, new discs and pads 60chf, 2 new tyres 90chf.

1 Like

Not where I live and use EKZ

1 Like

Even if that’s true (lots of citation missing here), the people paying that cost, are the people using the cars, so I guess in your version of events it serves them right? Or there is no externality there, at least as far as time is concerned.

Of course I do, fixed costs are paid regardless and depreciation for normal cars (i.e. not collector’s items) can be as dependent on time as they are on Km. Km actually tend to be cheaper the more you drive (on a relative/marginal basis). If you’re leasing and staying within the Km range, you actually pay per day and not per Km driven.

So even if I take the train, the car still sits at home and loses value, I still pay insurance, and I’ve replaced tires due to age more than I have due to wear and tear. Main services and associated costs are regular time intervals as well. There are some components that are on a distance basis (actual wear items like brakes, clutches, etc), but total cost of ownership and cost of trip should not judged on the same metrics.

One alternative is to not buy a car at all, then there are no fixed costs.

It would be silly to say buying a house is cheaper than renting because “if I rent I still have the cost of an empty house to maintain”!

1 Like

Is that still an issue?

Last time I took a car for the Swiss test my tires were very old but there was no comment on them although they did check them.

Legally, all good.

In the real world, old rubber is hard rubber :skull_and_crossbones:

If the car is driven 10k+ km per year, tires will probably wear before rubber degradation becomes a hazard. Oldtimers (3k km max per year) or nice cars only driven in salt-free roads don’t wear their tires before rubber becomes hard, so no traction and risk of blowing up.

3 Likes

Very much so. Beyond 5 years from manufacture they should be replaced. When buying new tyres it is worth making sure they are current stock and not from last year.